Black Star (The Door of No Return series, 2)

81l5apgvjVL
Age Range
8+
Release Date
September 24, 2024
ISBN
978-0316442596
Buy This Book
      
The thrilling second book in the #1 New York Times bestselling Door of No Return trilogy stars Kofi’s granddaughter, Charley, who’s set on becoming the first female pitcher to play professional ball but who soon has to contend with the tensions about to boil over in her segregated town.
You can’t protect her from knowing. The truth is all we have.

12-year old Charley Cuffey is many things: a granddaughter, a best friend, and probably the best pitcher in all of Lee’s Mill. Set on becoming the first female pitcher to play professional ball, Charley doesn't need reminders from her best friend Cool Willie Green to know that she has lofty dreams for a Black girl in the American South.

Even so, Nana Kofi's thrilling stories about courageous ancestors and epic journeys make it impossible not to dream big. She knows he has so many more to tell, but according to her parents, she isn't old enough to know about certain things like what happened to Booker Preston that one night in Great Bridge and why she can never play on the brand-new real deal baseball field on the other side of town.
 
When Charley challenges a neighborhood bully to a game at the church picnic, she knows she can win, even with her ragtag team. But when the picnic spills over onto their ball field, she makes a fateful decision.
 
A child cannot protect herself if she does not know her history, and Charley's choice brings consequences she never could have imagined.
 
In this riveting second book of the Door of No Return trilogy, set during the turbulent segregation era, and the beginning of The Great Migration, Kwame Alexander weaves a spellbinding story of struggle, determination, and the unflappable faith of an American family.

Editor review

1 review
Continued Family Saga
Overall rating
 
4.0
Plot
 
4.0
Characters
 
4.0
Writing Style
 
4.0
Illustrations/Photos (if applicable)
 
N/A
In the early 1920s, Charlene Cuffey is living in Virginia with her parents and her Nana Kofi, whose traumatic journey to the US in 1860 is detailed in The Door of No Return. Nana frequently tells her stories of his life in Africa, and he has a suitcase packed so that he can join Marcus Garvey once he manages to put together passage back to Africa for his followers. Charley, as she prefers to be called, has two good friends; Willie Green, who is also Black and idolizes baseball legends like Cool Papa Bell, and Henry Jones, who is white, and whose father owns the local mercantile. Charley's father once tried out for the D.C. Manhattans, but now works hard in Baltimore to support the family. Encouraged by her father's near success, Charley is convinced that she can someday play for the Negro Leagues, and is very excited when she hears that there are women in Philadelphia who have a league. Her aunt even brings her a secondhand baseball mitt that she says belonged to one of the players. The trio would love to play at the new ballfield at Great Bridge, but Black people are not allowed. They are trying to put together a team to play against local bully Cecil Holley, but struggling to find players. There is plenty of racial tension in the town; Nana owns 35 acres of land and regularly pays on his loans and is current on his taxes, which irritate white people who would like the land for themselves. When Mary McLeod Bethune comes to speak at the local church, Charley asks if her school has teams for girls. They don't, but Bethune thinks that Charley's inquisitive mind would make her a great teacher, and offers to talk to her about attending the school. Charley is reluctant, because she would miss her family, especially Nana, who has been very ill. When Henry, Will, and Charley run afoul of white teens, Charley and Will's lives are upended as they must quickly leave town to avoid tragedy.

Good Points
Like the first book in this series, Black Star is a novel in verse, although some sections (such as Nana's stories) are more prose like. The story moves along quickly, with plenty of details about church suppers, ball games, and Nana's stories. These give us a glimpse of what his life was like before Virginia, and also shows the lack of racial progress that was made during his time in the US.

The inclusion of real events and people, like Marcus Garvey and Mary McLeod Bethune, will hopefully encourage readers to find out more about these historic figures. It took me a little searching to figure out when this book was set, so I wish we had been given a specific year.

Sports are a great framework for historical fiction, and this begs to be read alongside Williams' fantastic Baseball's Leading Lady : Effa Manley and the Rise and Fall of the Negro Leagues. For a late date in history, Krishnaswami Step Up to the Plate, Maria Singh is a good readalike, and Stone's Fast Pitch covers some later baseball and racial history as well. Reader who want to delve more into what daily life was like for some Black people in the twentieth century would do well to pick up Wade Hudson's excellent Defiant: Growing Up in the Jim Crow South. I'm curious to see when Alexander will set the third book in this trilogy. We need a lot more books about the Great Migration.
Report this review Comments (0) | Was this review helpful? 0 0

User reviews

There are no user reviews for this listing.
Already have an account? or Create an account