Review Detail

 A middle grade graphic novel, CAMP PRODIGY is a cute story about two nonbinary kids at a summer music camp. We spend time with Tate and Eli as they become friends, practice music, and learn more about themselves. The story is told over the span of 4 weeks spent at the camp.

What I Loved:
The illustrations in this book were beautiful. The vivid colors and clean-cut images will draw readers into the story. The artwork is especially detailed when Eli or Tate is playing the viola and when their anxieties are becoming overwhelming. Despite some scenes having a lot of characters or background work, the text is still clearly readable.

The casual way that the two characters being nonbinary was handled was amazing! Eli had already come out by the beginning of the book and Tate is working on figuring themself out. There are anxieties associated with Tate’s journey, but them being nonbinary was handled well. Both characters’ identities felt authentic and handled well.

The story in this graphic novel is a sweet read, that felt perfectly geared towards summer. The tone is one that matches a middle grade level but it can also appeal to an older crowd as well, allowing many readers the opportunity to enjoy the book. While at camp, the two characters are having experiences that readers can relate to. There is enough conflict to allow for the story to keep moving forward, but it always maintains a lovely summery tone.

The author’s depiction of these characters and their experiences was well-executed. Both characters had moments where they suffered from anxiety or nerves and those emotions were never brushed off. They were taken seriously and the kids were given space and encouragement to work through their emotions. The author didn’t try to sugarcoat or dismiss the experience, rather the author showed ways in which the emotions can manifest and what helped the characters during those times.

What Left Me Wanting More:
The handling of Tate and Eli’s final issue at the end of the book felt a bit rushed. It felt like both the stress and the solution were rushed. They both work in the realm of the story, but it left the story feeling like it had started racing for no specific reason.

There were a lot of characters to keep track of in this book. A large cast allows readers to find a character that they identify with, but it may also leave some readers confused.

Final Verdict:
CAMP PRODIGY is a fun story with an enjoyable plot and a great message. The author wrote authentic characters who were struggling, but who were also learning that it’s okay to struggle and to lean on people. As a book geared towards kids, especially after the pandemic, that is a particularly important message to get across. Add in some gorgeous illustrations and likeable characters and readers will hopefully discover a fun read.

Centering on a tone of understanding and growth, CAMP PRODIGY turns into a beautiful symphony with the addition of vibrant illustrations and a note of summertime fun.