Review Detail
Middle Grade Fiction
64
Interesting look at a young Clara Barton
Overall rating
4.0
Plot
4.0
Characters
4.0
Writing Style
4.0
Illustrations/Photos (if applicable)
4.0
Maisie and Felix Robbins' lives are upturned in an instant when their parents announce they are divorcing. Before they know it, they are whisked from New York City to Newport, Rhode Island while their father packs himself off to work at a museum in Qatar! Because an ancestor built Elm Medona, one of the Gilded Age "cottages", and the children's great aunt Maisie can no longer stay in the apartment she is renting for $1 a year from the historical society, the children move in with their mother. They joke that they are being held captive in the attic, but it's quite a nice place to live, and they do get taken on a tour of their opulent new surroundings. While Maisie is not particularly happy about the move, she is intrigued, and when a pricelss Ming vase shatters, she surreptitiously picks up a shard. Things get strange when the vase appears later, fully mended! Felix doesn't think much of it until the two get a chance to see the Treasure Chest, a room full of all sorts of wonderful gifts that had been given to the owners of the home. When the two pick up a piece of paper, reality flickers, and they wonder what secrets the room might hold. Of course, their mother takes the day off, and wants them to visit their great aunt, but they are impatient to get back. When they sneak into the room at night, they manage to time travel! They end up in the country, and assume that the girl they meet in her family's barn, Clara Barton, must be Amish, and think they have traveled to Pennsylvania. When Clara tells them that they are in Massachusetts, and that it's 1836, they are amazed. They spend an interesting day hearing about Clara's brother David, who was sick and had to be nursed for three years, overhear stories that Clara's father tells, and have a hearty country breakfast. It's tricky to get back, and they realize that they have a letter that needs to be delivered to Clara. Once that is done, they head back to modern day Newport to start their new school, and to spend more time listening to their great aunt!
Good Points
If you have not been to Newport to see the mansions there, you should go if you get the chance. They are absolutely fascinating. There's so much history, and the thought of being able to live in an apartment in one of them... wow. I don't know why Maisie complains at all! The reasons for the family's move were solid, and I was glad that both Maisie and Felix saw some value in visiting their aunt and hearing her stories by the end of the book. The historical details about 1836 are good, and meeting a young Clara Barton and hearing about her formative years was interesting. I could use a good historical novel about Barton, now that I think about it. The new covers (this series first was published in 2011) are much better than the old ones.
Since Clara hasn't done her famous battlefield nursing work yet, this felt more like a Childhood of Famous Americans book than a time travel adventure where children have to rectify some anomaly in the past.
Asselin and Malone's Art of the Swap also takes place in a Newport mansion and involves time travel, but this has more historic significance. It will be popular with readers of Gutman's Flashback Four, Messner's Ranger in Time, or O'Brien's White House Clubhouse.
Since Clara hasn't done her famous battlefield nursing work yet, this felt more like a Childhood of Famous Americans book than a time travel adventure where children have to rectify some anomaly in the past.
Asselin and Malone's Art of the Swap also takes place in a Newport mansion and involves time travel, but this has more historic significance. It will be popular with readers of Gutman's Flashback Four, Messner's Ranger in Time, or O'Brien's White House Clubhouse.
Comments
Already have an account? Log in now or Create an account