Review Detail

What Left Me Wanting More:
Back in the day, when I was obsessed with chick lit, Sarah Mlynowski was one of the authors I loved to read. Seems like she followed me over to YA, but I’d actually not read any of her YA novels until now. I was actually a bit hesitant to try Don’t Even Think About It, because it sounded like the premise could easily go really wrong. At the same time, though, I was powerless to resist a book about people getting mind reading powers. Don’t Even Think About It is a totally silly, humorous fluff fest that kept me laughing along with the audiobook, which is masterfully performed.

Unlike most of the books that I read and enjoy, Don’t Even Think About It‘s strengths aren’t of characterization. The cast is a bit too large for me to be able to really emotionally bond with any of them. They do move past stereotypes in pretty much every case, but there’s really just not too much screen time spent on any one character. In fact, the biggest weakness was the distance placed between the audience and the individuals by the narrative style.

Mlynowski chose to tell Don’t Even Think About It as though the entire class is sitting down together and crafting the story. It’s obviously a stylistic choice, but not one which particularly worked for me. Any time the “we” would show up, I’d tilt my head at the audiobook for a bit and then carry on my merry way. It didn’t end up being a huge detractor, but it definitely didn’t add to my experience, and a third person perspective would have performed the same role but been less distracting.

What I Liked:
Aside from those factors, though, Don’t Even Think About It was just SO much fun. Now, the premise is totally one that you just have to run with. It’s utterly improbable and I’m sure science would frown at it, but science and I aren’t really on speaking terms, so I don’t care. This homeroom class goes to get flu shots and, everyone who got the shot gets telepathic powers. It totally bums me out that I would have been one of the two people in class without telepathy, but not enough to change my mind about the flu shot.

Don’t Even Think About It stays pretty surface level. It’s a comedy, not a deep consideration of the impact abilities like mind reading would have on a young mind. The goal is to make you smile, not to make you do a whole lot of thinking. That said, I was actually impressed at the range of themes that Mlynowski touched on in a meaningful way. She may not have gone too deep, but a lot of characters did have their little personal growth arcs that were really positive. I especially loved watching Olivia come out of her shell a bit. There’s some over the top drama, but I also had a couple of cute ships to root for, so it kind of balanced out.

What impressed me most about this book, though, was the audiobook. I mean, holy shit. There are SO many characters and there’s narration, spoken dialog AND thought dialog. This could easily have been confusing to the level of being incomprehensible. Listening Library totally hit this one out of the park. For one thing, Erin Spencer has a great voice for this book. She totally pulls off the sort of pampered teen thing without sounding obnoxious. Plus, they managed to clearly differentiate the spoken and thought dialog by making all of the thoughts sound like they were spoken in a hollow space. It was very effective, and I never had any problems following along..

The Final Verdict:
If you like your books to be super serious and stuff, then Don’t Even Think About It probably isn’t a great choice for you. However, if, like me, you’re a sucker for mind reading plots, can embrace silliness, and don’t mind some teen romantic drama, I totally recommend this for when you’re looking for something light. Also, the audiobook is FANtastic, so, if you like those, then I would like to push the audiobook version at you, because it’s brilliant.