Review Detail

What worked:
The story is told from Semma’s point of view as she lives in an orphanage with her twin sister Trooni. They retrieve their cousin, Rascal, to search for their only living relative, an old, estranged uncle named Bumbrain. Their previous guardian’s last wish was that the cousins should not, under any circumstances, have any form of contact with Uncle Bumbrain. This adds intrigue to the story when Semma and Trooni set off to seek him out on their twelfth birthday. The man has always sent them gifts and he’s the only positive thing left in their lives. What could go wrong with meeting him in Stuffmore?
The characters offer distinct, contrasting personalities. Trooni is very logical and linear as she immediately tries to create step-by-step plans for every situation. She tends to lose her cool when others make spontaneous decisions and Rascal kiddingly calls her “Mom”. Rascal’s lack of inhibition makes him the exact opposite of his cousin. He wants to have fun and he’s prone to running off on his own. Semma’s personality is full of emotions and kindness toward others and she’s especially loyal to her twin sister. She wants to be part of a loving family. Semma gets feelings about her surroundings that others do not and she begins to have visions too once they reach Stuffmore. The visions complicate the plot and lead it new directions.
Greed is a major topic in the book and it doesn’t paint a pretty picture. Everyone in Stuffmore is obsessed with their standing on the city’s happiness list and all of their time is spent trying to move up. Even Uncle Bumbrain quickly gets back in the race after he appears to be pleased about the children’s arrival. Citizens fill their days doing non-stop shopping without spending time looking at what they’re bought. Semma becomes concerned when her uncle, sister, and cousin don’t leave even a moment to use what they’ve purchased or to have friendly talks as a family. The motivating idea in Stuffmore is quantity since having everything you might possibly want will make you happy.
What didn’t work as well:
Readers may wonder how the citizens are able to keep continuously buy more stuff every day when no one has a job. Buying bigger houses and cars will move a person up the happiness list but why can’t everyone do that? Where are all these products made and what limits citizens from buying everything? The list creates a hierarchy of citizens that promotes competition to buy more stuff.
The final verdict:
This wacky adventure into another world shares a lesson in greed and the search for happiness. The characters battle real-life inner thoughts and feelings that are taken to extreme levels. The blend of humor, serious, and zany will appeal to many young, able readers and I recommend you give this new series a shot.