Review Detail
Middle Grade Fiction
182
The Lonesome Prairie
(Updated: February 17, 2012)
Overall rating
5.0
Plot
N/A
Characters
N/A
Writing Style
N/A
Illustrations/Photos (if applicable)
N/A
Like Caroline Starr Rose, I too was an avid fan of all the Laura Ingalls Wilder books. I admired Laura's wildness, but I also admired the serene order imposed on her life -- and on frontier life -- by her mother. No matter what, the floor was swept, the table clean, the pantry orderly and the children safe, their clothes pressed and their ribbons tied.
May B., like Laura, is a pioneer girl, living with her family on the Kansas prairie, and like the Ingalls, May's family and life are ordered and content. Her father farms, her mother keeps house, and May and her brother do their chores and go to school. May does have one concern -- she struggles to learn to read (and it's clear that she likely has dyslexia, but that's our modern understanding) and she's worried that her dream of being a teacher will therefore never come to pass.
Her worries are about to multiply, however. When this lovely verse novel opens, May is being sent away, to be the hired girl at a house thirty miles from home. The family needs the money, and this is how she can help. May is miserable, but determined, and even takes her school books so she can continue to learn even though she can't go to school.
The household she enters though, is far from happy. The wife, an Easterner, is miserable in Kansas, living in a soddy (a sod house) that leaks when it rains, which has snakes nesting in the roof and mud for a floor. When the woman suddenly flees, and her husband goes after her, May is left alone. As the days pass and no one returns, May realizes she is going to be on her own for a long time. With no way to get home, and with no neighbor nearer than twenty miles, she is completely isolated. And the wolves are howling at the door.
How May faces her troubles, and how she comes to accept her limitations, as well as live into her strengths, makes for inspiring reading. The quick, verse lines are sparse and as strong as pioneers homesteading on that grassland, and each word, each line sends the story hurtling forward at a breath-holding pace. The author makes May's world come alive, details woven into the narrative so easily and naturally that a reader sinks completely into this bygone age, and lives it along with a heroine who is as strong and admirable as Laura Ingalls herself.
May B., like Laura, is a pioneer girl, living with her family on the Kansas prairie, and like the Ingalls, May's family and life are ordered and content. Her father farms, her mother keeps house, and May and her brother do their chores and go to school. May does have one concern -- she struggles to learn to read (and it's clear that she likely has dyslexia, but that's our modern understanding) and she's worried that her dream of being a teacher will therefore never come to pass.
Her worries are about to multiply, however. When this lovely verse novel opens, May is being sent away, to be the hired girl at a house thirty miles from home. The family needs the money, and this is how she can help. May is miserable, but determined, and even takes her school books so she can continue to learn even though she can't go to school.
The household she enters though, is far from happy. The wife, an Easterner, is miserable in Kansas, living in a soddy (a sod house) that leaks when it rains, which has snakes nesting in the roof and mud for a floor. When the woman suddenly flees, and her husband goes after her, May is left alone. As the days pass and no one returns, May realizes she is going to be on her own for a long time. With no way to get home, and with no neighbor nearer than twenty miles, she is completely isolated. And the wolves are howling at the door.
How May faces her troubles, and how she comes to accept her limitations, as well as live into her strengths, makes for inspiring reading. The quick, verse lines are sparse and as strong as pioneers homesteading on that grassland, and each word, each line sends the story hurtling forward at a breath-holding pace. The author makes May's world come alive, details woven into the narrative so easily and naturally that a reader sinks completely into this bygone age, and lives it along with a heroine who is as strong and admirable as Laura Ingalls herself.
Good Points
Evocative of its time
Detailed
Easy to read
Detailed
Easy to read
Comments
5 results - showing 1 - 5
Ordering
Already have an account? Log in now or Create an account
February 21, 2012
I didn't realize this was a verse novel when the list went out. I'm in a huge verse novel phase right now, so will have to check this one out at the library!
Megan Kelly
February 21, 2012
I am so interested in reading this one. Thanks for your review!
Claire Johnson, Staff Reviewer
February 24, 2012
In reply to an earlier comment
Yay! You'll enjoy it, I think.
Francesca Amendolia
February 24, 2012
In reply to an earlier comment
I know! The only problem I have with verse novels (and it's not really a problem) is that I can't put them down. I walk around with them as if I've been glued to the book. I stay up too late to finish them. It's like guzzling. I guzzle verse novels.
Francesca Amendolia
March 15, 2012
In reply to an earlier comment
That is the perfect way to describe it: I guzzle verse novels!
Megan Kelly
5 results - showing 1 - 5