Review Detail

[I am going to have to get into mild spoiler territory here. I've been pondering how to avoid it, and I just can't. It's alluded to very early in the book though, and I don't think your enjoyment will be lessened knowing this in advance. Even so, my apologies.]

First off, this book is nothing like what I expected (I should mention that I checked it out from the library as an e-book, so I didn't know that it's typically classified -- mis-classified, in my humble opinion -- in the horror genre). I thought it was going to be a bittersweet story of a young boy digging into his grandfather's tragic past, and learning a valuable lesson. I knew creepy vintage photos were incorporated, but I figured they'd be like a metaphor for the way his grandfather had tried to dress up what had happened to him, to make it all seem magical and mysterious instead of just sad and depressing.

Because I was thinking that "tragic past" meant something like "Holocaust survivor." I was pretty sure monsters = Nazis.

But no. Monsters = freakin' monsters.

This story is full of fantasy, magic, and unexpected twists and turns that totally blew my mind. I had no idea where it was going, and when I turned the last page, I found myself dumbly attempting to flip another non-existent page, and yelling, "that's it?!"

Needless to say, I sincerely hope Mr. Riggs goes forward with the sequel(s).

What makes Miss Peregrine's even more interesting is the vintage photography that is incorporated into the story. Authentic (yes, they're real!) and decidedly creepy photos are woven seamlessly into the narrative, adding a level of realism and creepiness that both grounds the story and enhances its impact.

It's not without its flaws. It is a little slow to get moving. Jacob spends a good chunk of time on the island before anything really happens. But once it took off, I couldn't put it down.

Keep in mind, I definitely think it's mis-classified as horror. It's much closer to YA/mid-grade fantasy. I think the cover misleads people (bad font choice, publisher). I don't think the intent of the book is to scare the reader; I think it's to enthrall and amaze. So there are a lot of people out there who are kind of peeved that this book "wasn't scary enough." I'm obviously not one of them. No, it's not scary. It's creepy (which can be attributed largely to the photos), but mostly it's just a fantastical adventure story.