Review Detail

What worked:
Standing up to unfairness can be tough for middle-grade students and that issue is at the forefront of Justin’s concerns. He was punched in the stomach for reporting a bully and now he’s gun-shy about new problems he encounters. He doesn’t say or do anything when a cabin bully picks on his friend and afterward, he laments his inaction. One of his closest friends Naz has darker skin and Justin doesn’t speak up when Naz experiences prejudice. Justin’s also confused by his counselor’s apparent disinterest and negativity toward him so he’s not sure who to turn to for help.
The book blends elements of magic with the realistic problems found at Camp Inch. Justin, Darby, and Naz are able to mentally communicate due to the powers they were given by the spirit of Leroy Usher in the previous book. Their magic only works when they’re together and they soon realize it will only work when they cooperate. Or does it? Usher’s spirit summons the kids to visit his warehouse throughout the book where they’re transported back in time to different moments in his life. These trips were accomplished on a carnival ride in the first book but the kids enter a magical elevator this time.
The flashbacks into Usher’s past present situations that hopefully help Justin and his friends learn ways to deal with their own problems. A visit back to 7-year-old Leroy’s life reveals his father’s prejudice toward people of color. Justin and his friends are confused when they see young Leroy has a talent and love for music yet his grown children today are unaware of this part of their father’s life. Justin is also puzzled by the anger unleashed upon him by his cabin friend Eugene. His feelings are even more perplexed when he sees Eugene buddying up to the bully. Eugene won’t talk to Justin anymore so Justin searches for Mr. Usher’s wisdom regarding how to navigate the difficulties of doing the right thing.
What didn’t work as well:
The plot doesn’t have a dramatic conflict so readers won’t feel the same suspense and tension they might get in other books. However, Justin’s problems are realistic and they’re very stressful to those who are dealing with them.
The final verdict:
It’s not necessary to have read the first book but it might help to understand the kids’ relationship with Leroy Usher. The issues associated with “doing the right thing” are at the forefront of the story and the support Justin receives from his friends is universal. Overall, this book is engaging and pleasurable and I recommend you give it a shot.