Review Detail

Previously published on my blog: http://fictionfervor.wordpress.com/2011/06/27/review-the-iron-witch-by-karen-mahoney/

I was actually pretty disappointed with The Iron Witch. The idea the book was based on was so intriguing, and yet the book itself fell flat.

Donna is an alchemist. And not the changing-things-to-gold alchemist, the killing-pesky-fairies-on-earth alchemist. And not just any killing-pesky-fairies-on-earth alchemist. Others expect her to be a child prodigy, considering that she’s the daughter of two fantastic alchemists. Even though her father is dead and her mother has probably gone crazy.

Her mother went crazy after Donna’s father died in an accident. Not a car accident. An accident caused by the fairies. And this accident has left Donna with arms made of iron. Repaired by the alchemists, her arms have made her superman-strong.

So when the fairies kidnap her best friend Navin, you’d expect her to be kick-butt strong.

She isn’t. Though strong, Donna definitely isn’t kick-butt. Being kick-butt means being smart, strong, and fearless. Donna is not smart at times. She’s pretty idiotic. (I’d love to give examples as to why she’s so incredibly stupid, but that would take paragraphs.) And though she has strong down, she is not fearless.

And whereas Donna annoyed me so much, Xan was a relief. Xan is definitely one of those hot boys that you can’t help but swoon a little bit over (yes, I have a mild crush on him), but he’s also pretty fearless. More than Donna, at least. And though Xan sort of has a “haunted past,” there’s also something about Xan that makes him pretty special. That something is the part that I made white in the synopsis. Because it’s obviously a spoiler.

Oh, boy, I hate spoilers in synopses.

And Navin? Oh, I love Navin. Although I’m Team Xan without a doubt, Navin is awesome. Because he’s her best friend and one of the only people she cares about. He’s Indian, too, which definitely gives him bonus points in my mind, purely because I love nerdy best friends.

I don’t know if Karen Mahoney plans to make a love triangle with Donna, Xan, and Navin in it; but frankly, I don’t really believe Donna deserves to have two boys after her. (Yes, I don’t like Donna that much.) I’d say Xan and Navin were the only things that kept me reading this book. Because I just love hot boys and Indian best friends.

Things I’d like to say about the book? These are only minor details, but I still feel that I should voice my thoughts.

I’m a grammar Nazi (though I write pretty casually in my reviews). I’m pretty sure that I’ve already established that several times. Anyway, the writing in this book was decent, but I did reach this one sentence that had me gaping in horror. “Who’d’ve thunk it?” Seriously? “Who’d’ve”? I slightly understand that one because this word has become slang among teenagers these days, but then “thunk”? THUNK? I am incredibly sad now.

Another thing. Navin’s parents let Navin and Donna stay in a bedroom with no supervisors. Though that might seem pretty normal to you Americans, I’m not used to that. Remember, I’m Chinese? Chinese and Indian parents are pretty strict with schoolwork and dating. Yes, so that’s just a little bit hard to believe that they could stay in Navin’s bedroom for a pretty long time without supervisors. Even if Navin’s parents trusted both of them enough, it’s just too outrageous for my ears to believe. I know it was necessary for the book because Donna had to tell Navin some important things, but still. Highly improbable.

And lastly, this is the thing that bothered me most about the book. The ending is so sudden. It’s pretty much an anticlimax. All of a sudden, Donna tells us in a sort of epilogue (spoiler!) that she’s going on trial. Wow. It’s like, “Oh, hey, I’m going on trial! See you in the next book!” I practically forgot that she was even going to trial. That bad.

The Iron Witch was a frustrating read for me. At times, it was too predictable, and then at other times it was too improbable, and then at other times it was too sudden. Though I had general liking for the characters (except for Donna), the plot wasn’t the most intriguing that it could be. I felt as if Karen Mahoney could have done more with the incredible idea the book was based on.

Source: copy borrowed from library