Review Detail
Young Adult Fiction
303
We Are Not Free
(Updated: February 04, 2020)
Overall rating
5.0
Plot
N/A
Characters
N/A
Writing Style
N/A
Illustrations/Photos (if applicable)
N/A
Fourteen friends who grew up together in Japantown, San Francisco find themselves and their families sent off to incarceration camps during WWII. Each of them have their own stories. Stories that show the pain, racism, and fear they feel being uprooted from their homes. But it's also a story with joy, laughter, and the power of friendship.
What worked: This is one powerful, gripping tale of Japanese American teens who find themselves ripped from their homes and sent with their families to harsh incarceration camps after the Pearl Harbor attack. What I loved about this story is it shows the human emotions each of these friends feels being forced to leave everything they know behind. Each character is multi-layered. There's optimistic Hiromi 'Bette' who tries to find some joy in even the bleakest situations. Minnow, who loves to draw subjects around him, including his friends and scenes from the camps. Mas, who tries to look out for all his friends.
There are some intense scenes that don't hold back on the horrific conditions within the camps. Or the blatant racism shown even to those who come back from serving our country. There's one scene where Mas is walking down the street with a Black soldier and a white man bumps him and snarls a hateful word his way.
Mas's reflections...If I go to war for America, if I kill for America, if I support an America that doesn't support me, am I supporting my oppressors? Am I killing their enemies so they can later kill me?
There's some really powerful writing throughout, including Twitchy's tour overseas. The alternating short and long sentences drive home the intensity of war. Readers witness the horrors first hand and the bravery of the 442 Regimental Combat team.
One of the other friends is torn on whether or not he should renounce his citizenship. He sees first hand what happens when those, including his parents, sign no to the allegiance oath that all those who are incarcerated are forced to sign.
Powerful, gripping tale of Japanese American friends forced into WWII incarceration camps. This strong tale shows the importance of remembering the past, but it also shows the power of friendship.
What worked: This is one powerful, gripping tale of Japanese American teens who find themselves ripped from their homes and sent with their families to harsh incarceration camps after the Pearl Harbor attack. What I loved about this story is it shows the human emotions each of these friends feels being forced to leave everything they know behind. Each character is multi-layered. There's optimistic Hiromi 'Bette' who tries to find some joy in even the bleakest situations. Minnow, who loves to draw subjects around him, including his friends and scenes from the camps. Mas, who tries to look out for all his friends.
There are some intense scenes that don't hold back on the horrific conditions within the camps. Or the blatant racism shown even to those who come back from serving our country. There's one scene where Mas is walking down the street with a Black soldier and a white man bumps him and snarls a hateful word his way.
Mas's reflections...If I go to war for America, if I kill for America, if I support an America that doesn't support me, am I supporting my oppressors? Am I killing their enemies so they can later kill me?
There's some really powerful writing throughout, including Twitchy's tour overseas. The alternating short and long sentences drive home the intensity of war. Readers witness the horrors first hand and the bravery of the 442 Regimental Combat team.
One of the other friends is torn on whether or not he should renounce his citizenship. He sees first hand what happens when those, including his parents, sign no to the allegiance oath that all those who are incarcerated are forced to sign.
Powerful, gripping tale of Japanese American friends forced into WWII incarceration camps. This strong tale shows the importance of remembering the past, but it also shows the power of friendship.
Good Points
1. Powerful, gripping tale of Japanese American friends during WWII internment camps
Comments
Already have an account? Log in now or Create an account