
About This Book:
*Review Contributed By Karen Yingling, Staff Reviewer*
Good sportsmanship on and off the field
The coaches were the best part of this for me, because they modeled very positive behavior and encouraged the team to support each other and work together. Books like Greenwald’s The Good Sports League series are becoming more common, so hopefully good sportsmanship will see a resurgence!
Fabiola and Seba’s experiences with language are very true to life. Fabiola often uses her phone to translate her conversations, which I have seen students do, but I appreciated that her mother encouraged her NOT to rely on the phone too much. Having a lot of Spanish included in the book will help young readers to understand how hard it is to come to another country and have to pick up a new language!
Nicky is a complicated character who carries a lot of anger that comes from her personal life, and her desired career trajectory is something middle school students envision, and also adds to her frustration and anger. Palmer is fairly philosophical about being out for the season, but is still invested in his team. Gonzalez has clearly spent some time around middle school soccer teams!
It’s been over fifty years since Title IX, and while the world isn’t perfect, it still feels extremely antiquated for boys to complain that girls are on their teams. We’ve had girls on the football team at my middle school, and no one cared. I thought we were catching up, with books like Lupica’s Triple Threat series or Green’s Final Season, but just like the real world, I guess we are seeing backsliding in girls’ and women’s rights.
This is a good choice for readers who liked sports books centering on girls playing for boys’ teams, like Marino’s Iced Out, or who are interested in the experience of English language learners. The story was a lot of fun, so graphic novel readers will be sure to pick this one up.
