Review Detail

Game of Scones is the first book in a new series from illustrator "The Doodle Boy" Joe Whale and Eric Luper. Here readers are introduced to the food in the cafeteria at Belching Walrus Elementary. The story follows Slice (pizza), Scoop (ice cream), and Totz (a tater tot) as they battle for independence from the Main Office, specifically Baron Von Lineal (a ruler). Creativity and imagination abound in this story, filled with all the things from school and what they get up to when the students are away.

What I Enjoyed:
I really enjoyed the creativity and liberties taken in the story. This is a Game of Thrones style showdown, complete with a "Blue Meeting" and epic betrayals. I particularly enjoyed the use of items found at school as the characters: food from the cafeteria, office supplies from the main office, books from the library, instruments from the music room, gym equipment and art supplies. Each group of items makes up its own tribe within the school, and the action is driven by the Main Office's need to rule them all.

What Left Me Wanting More:
While the creativity and art throughout the book are engaging, I needed more clarity among the characters. There are times it is confusing about which character is speaking or leading the charge, and the art doesn't always match what's happening on page.
This book is billed for ages 6 and up, however the language used and action that takes place is more appropriate for upper elementary, even middle grade. I don't believe that it will hold a younger reader's attention as it would an older one.

Final Thoughts:
Game of Scones is a fun, creative story that will engage older readers and leave them wondering what happens at school when they aren't there.