Review Detail

Reader reviewed by Kayci

Speak, although predictable, gave an unabashed portrayal of a female teenage outcast grappling with emotions that she cannot even bring herself to communicate. The book was frustrating at times as I felt like it was forcing the metaphor issue with the art class and communication. Also, the lack of dialogue became problematic for me especially as it became pretty obvious what was going on yet the character would never fully communicate that until almost the end. If the author did this intentionally to give the reader insight into how the main character felt about her inability to communicate, then it was certainly a success but it seemed dragged out towards the end. The portrayal of friendships and peer relationships was a bit exaggerated for me, particularly with the portrayal of cliques and Melindas friends blatant lack of concern for her; not giving her so much as a phone call post-party to ask her what was up. Also, the main characters unsympathetic parents and administrators added another level of frustration in that everything felt a little too set-up and fit in a little too well. There were no unexpected characters and that made the book forced and boring by the end of it. Perhaps its that many other books and storylines have been produced post-Speak that made the storyline and characters predictable. However, as far as tackling a serious issue and giving it an honest portrayal, the book does well in portraying Melindas inability to communicate and her state as an outcast. There are unexpected humorous moments and deeply emotional moments as well. While the book becomes predictable, the overall experience is honest and makes for a good read and good discussion piece.