Review Detail

WHERE THE DARK STANDS STILL is an intriguing YA fantasy about a young woman who does not belong and seeks to remove the part of herself that has caused her to be an outlier. Liska has magic, something that is not allowed by the church nor the other villagers. Her mother is very cold to her, seeking to prevent her using or getting caught having magic. On a special night, Liska has traveled into the mythically dangerous woods to find a flower that will grant her wish - to have her magic taken away.

Although she has a harrowing journey confronted by spirits and demons, she finds the flower, only to encounter the Leszy, the demon warden of the woods. He offers her a bargain - a year of servitude in exchange for her wish. Feeling as though her options are limited, Liska agrees to the bargain and begins to live with the 700-year-old Leszy. What she begins to learn are the truths about magic, the woods, and the warden who maintains them, as well as, importantly, truths about herself and where she belongs.

What I loved: This was a lush fantasy with a magical house, interesting spirits, and a large mystery that drives the story forward. Liska is at the center of it all, trying to understand what the house and the spirits are trying to tell her. She has lived her life fearing her magic and not really knowing anything about it. Now, understanding that her magic has a role to play in keeping the people around the woods safe, Liska is trying to undo the years of suppressing it and all of the lessons she has internalized. Her story is one of personal growth and coming-of-age as she begins to consider herself and her magic anew.

Beyond Liska, I found some of the secondary characters particularly compelling, such as Jaga, the house spirit who has quite the attitude and adds some fun to the story. Other characters who appear later were also really lovely and added to the story nicely (not specifying to avoid spoilers). The Leszy was also intriguing, of course, for all the secrets he has kept and for the things hidden in his past. He is a complicated character who combines morally good and bad facets into what he is now. His story has a redemption arc as Liska begins to learn of his past and with what happens beyond.

Themes around home/found family, religion and its relation to paganism/magic/history, faith, fitting in, grief/loss, regret, horrible/large mistakes, self-forgiveness and understanding, and what makes a life were all really thought-provoking. The truths of the history, spirits, demons, old gods, and magic were juxtaposed with the teachings of the church, the way the religion was interpreted for/by the citizens, and the way this has morphed over time. The morality of it was murky with some general value to the process but also the danger that lies within these changes for people like Liska or others who do not seem to conform. This is not viewed as a negative thing in all cases, and it was interesting to see this discussion develop throughout the book.

Found family was another strong theme of the story, and Liska really begins to find her place in the world as the story continues. The ending was bittersweet with a strong note of hope that will speak to readers (and may need some tissues). It was quite a powerful and impactful journey without an easy end, even though it felt satisfying and lovely.

What left me wanting more: As for small things, the beginning of the story moves very slowly and felt somewhat circular. The second half of the book really sped things up and was absolutely riveting, so it was definitely worth sticking with it. The romance has a large age-gap, and it seemed to build very quickly, which will work for some readers more than others.

Final verdict: WHERE THE DARK STANDS STILL is a thought-provoking and emotional YA fantasy with a touch of romance, mythology, and magic.