Review Detail
Evil-Ish
Featured
Young Adult Fiction
1781
Evil-ish
(Updated: June 15, 2026)
Overall rating
3.3
Plot
4.0
Characters
2.0
Writing Style
3.0
Illustrations/Photos (if applicable)
4.0
Good:
While the character art wasn't my favorite, I did really enjoy the aesthetic. And I'll always be amazed at people's skills. I also thought the idea was cute.
What didn't resonant with me:
The characters. I just didn't understand Hawthorne's character. His wanting to be "evil" but he just wanted to be a prank bro instead. It just didn't really make sense why he was the way he was and his evolving was very flat.
Some of the scene jumps were just too much. It went really quickly from one scene to the next in the middle which made me feel a little whip lashed.
Recommended audience:
I think this will do great for the intended audience, more of the younger side of the spectrum. While this does have some redeeming qualities - I think there was a lot more for the wanting.
But I loved Maple. She was the best character from start to finish.
While the character art wasn't my favorite, I did really enjoy the aesthetic. And I'll always be amazed at people's skills. I also thought the idea was cute.
What didn't resonant with me:
The characters. I just didn't understand Hawthorne's character. His wanting to be "evil" but he just wanted to be a prank bro instead. It just didn't really make sense why he was the way he was and his evolving was very flat.
Some of the scene jumps were just too much. It went really quickly from one scene to the next in the middle which made me feel a little whip lashed.
Recommended audience:
I think this will do great for the intended audience, more of the younger side of the spectrum. While this does have some redeeming qualities - I think there was a lot more for the wanting.
But I loved Maple. She was the best character from start to finish.
Comments
Already have an account? Log in now or Create an account
