Review Detail

Please Be My Star offers a unique retelling of the famous novel/musical, The Phantom of the Opera as a YA romantic comedy. For those unfamiliar with the original source, the story follows the narrative of a disfigured musical genius who haunts the Paris Opera House and falls in love with the young soprano, Christine, and her talents. The graphic novel has role reversal in this retelling as the main character Erika, has a deep passion for writing and creating stories, and the boy in her theatre class becomes her muse. But as she the closer she grows to him, she fears the risks of putting her heart on the line and if Christian will return her feelings.

Wonderfully illustrated (similar to a manga style) and written, Elliott has crafted a relatable story for teenagers during their coming-of-age period in life. I could relate to myself as an adult with Erika’s experience of geeky interests that may seem “weird” and that overbearing feeling of wanting acceptance. I think teenagers as well as older readers will be able to see themselves in the characters of this story as they work through their obstacles. Some struggle to make friends, some are lonely, and others just want to feel loved I felt like the novel is a light-hearted but important message of being yourself and growing from the past.

Though it reads quickly I found this story to be very enjoyable. My only complaint is that I would have liked to have seen more development for other characters heavily featured as part of Erika’s theatre team. I wish the graphic novel was longer to expand on some of the character relationships more and that the resolution of the problem wasn’t so rushed too. But overall, I think for the page length given for this graphic novel it’s a cohesive story with cute artwork, witty banter that you find in most romantic comedies, and features a lively cast of characters.

If you enjoy stories of self-discovery or retellings of classic tales, add Please Be My Star to your reading list!