Review Detail

What I Loved:

Older’s worldbuilding is some of the most vivid and creative I’ve ever come across. Graffiti and murals–two types of art often sneered at as “vandalism, not art”–are explicitly turned into something good, culturally important, and powerful. The world is saved not with fists but with art and brains. This is a novel written with a deep knowledge of and love for New York City and the culture these characters come from. It takes us back to the sweet, sweet roots of urban fantasy.

Though the novel is deeply entrenched in Caribbean myth, Older doesn’t neglect contemporary issues his characters face either. Sierra has to deal with colorism from her aunt and many comments about her wild hair. Her best friend’s brother died at the hands of police who brutally murdered him. Even as murals cry and her grandfather’s friends start dying off one by one at the hands of a power-hungry white man, this is our very uncomfortable, horrible world in all its glory.

Speaking of the good researcher who goes mad with power, the scenario of a white man jumping into a POC culture and nearly destroying it may sound familiar to anyone who knows their history. The way the status quo gets turned around is brilliant and more novels should give it a shot!

What Left Me Wanting:

At 304 pages, Shadowshaper is extraordinarily short for a standalone fantasy novel. It got me worried about the novel’s pacing and development, which turned into the two major issues I have with it. Character development and training for Sierra are rushed through with lightning-fast speed; secondary characters are mere sketches. Robbie had to train for years to reach the level he’s at, but it takes Sierra mere hours to be his equal because she’s immediately good at it. There’s a good reason for that, but it doesn’t make for a lot of fun to see her accomplish in minutes what took Robbie years of training to do. Shadowshaper puts you in a speedboat when the experience should be more like a cruise so you can admire what’s around you. The ending wraps up neatly and yet there needs to be so much more than there is.

Final Verdict:

Older heard readers crying for more creative, diverse reads and he answered with a novel as rich and unique as it is fun and fast-paced. I haven’t read adult urban fantasy in years, but knowing Older has such a series makes me want to get back into that genre.