Review Detail
4.1 7
Young Adult Fiction
519
Magic Under Glass not so Magical
(Updated: July 01, 2026)
Overall rating
3.0
Plot
3.0
Characters
N/A
Writing Style
N/A
Illustrations/Photos (if applicable)
N/A
Reader reviewed by vicky
Magic Under Glass is author Jaclyn Dolamore's first novel. It begins with a young woman named Nimira who works as a music-hall girl. This is a great fall from her family's position in her home country. She sings for pennies just to survive. So she thinks that she has been given a wonderful oppurtunity when a wealthy sorcerer hires her to perform with a piano playing automaton. However things are not what they appear. The automaton is not just a mechanical piece of art and Hollin Parry, the magician harbors a horrible secret.
This book has a great plot but the climax falls a little short. Though, the book is decent for a first novel I have read better. It just doesn't give the reader the sense of magic that I believe most are looking for when they read a book that is suppose to be a fairy tale or fantasy. I believe a younger reader, say an advanced reader of 9 or 10, might enjoy it more than I did but some of the situations are a little too mature for that age group. The ending left it open for a sequel but I doubt that I will follow up on rather or not one is published. This book wasn't that bad, it just wasn't that goos either.
Magic Under Glass is author Jaclyn Dolamore's first novel. It begins with a young woman named Nimira who works as a music-hall girl. This is a great fall from her family's position in her home country. She sings for pennies just to survive. So she thinks that she has been given a wonderful oppurtunity when a wealthy sorcerer hires her to perform with a piano playing automaton. However things are not what they appear. The automaton is not just a mechanical piece of art and Hollin Parry, the magician harbors a horrible secret.
This book has a great plot but the climax falls a little short. Though, the book is decent for a first novel I have read better. It just doesn't give the reader the sense of magic that I believe most are looking for when they read a book that is suppose to be a fairy tale or fantasy. I believe a younger reader, say an advanced reader of 9 or 10, might enjoy it more than I did but some of the situations are a little too mature for that age group. The ending left it open for a sequel but I doubt that I will follow up on rather or not one is published. This book wasn't that bad, it just wasn't that goos either.
G
Guest
Comments
Already have an account? Log in now or Create an account
