The Metamorphosis of Bunny Baxter

 
4.8 (2)
 
5.0 (2)
1313 0
91krDCik5DL
Author(s)
Age Range
8+
Release Date
July 22, 2025
ISBN
978-0823458561
Buy This Book
     
If Bunny Baxter were an insect, she’d have so many ways to slip through seventh grade unnoticed. But she’s tall instead of tiny, has flaming red Medusa hair instead of camouflage, and she suffers from social anxiety, which makes it hard to be part of a swarm. Worst of all, she’s been redistricted to a new middle school away from her best friend who she could always hide behind when her anxiety got the best of her.

The first day at E.D. Britt Middle School does not go well. Bunny trips on the steps, falls into the cutest boy in the school, and causes a kid domino pile-up. At lunch, she unintentionally causes an uproar in the cafeteria, which lands her and another girl in the principal’s office. Bunny decides there is only one option: to get expelled so she can transfer to the school her best friend attends.

She soon discovers that it isn’t that hard to get in trouble—don’t turn in your homework, walk around the track instead of run in P.E., pretend you deliberately hit someone with a badminton birdie. What isn’t so easy for Bunny is realizing she now has a reputation as a troublemaker. And even more confusing, when it looks like her plan to get expelled might work, she’s no longer sure what to do.

The Metamorphosis of Bunny Baxter is a heartfelt coming of age story about an insect-loving girl who is learning to grow into herself—quirks and all.

Editor reviews

2 reviews
Discovering Oneself
(Updated: June 04, 2026)
Overall rating
 
5.0
Plot
 
5.0
Characters
 
5.0
Writing Style
 
5.0
Illustrations/Photos (if applicable)
 
N/A
“The Metamorphosis of Bunny Baxter” by Barbara Carroll Roberts takes readers on a journey as Bunny tries to get kicked out of her new school. She can’t understand why the district had to redraw the lines for where she goes to school, and now her best friend and other close friends are going to Wade’s Run for middle school, while she’s stuck at E.D. Britt.

Even though she finds herself talking to some kids at her new school, she is immediately thrust into the spotlight when she knocks over one of the eighth grade boys on her first day of school, and then finds herself in the principal’s office when a girl who was bothering her turns the tables on Bunny, making it seem like Bunny was to blame for the disturbance in the cafeteria.

All she wants is to be back with her friends at Wade’s Run, but to do that, she knows she has to get into trouble—something she has never really done—as that is how she will get sent to an alternative school. Little does she know that she doesn’t really get to choose where she goes to school—the district does. Finding a way to deal with the repercussions of the trouble she has wreaked in her new school and on her new classmates isn’t going to be easy, but she knows she has to do it to save face, even if just a little.

Bunny finds, through her getting into trouble experiment, that sometimes things aren’t quite what they seem, and sometimes what you’re looking for may be right under your nose, even if you’re not seeing it. This coming-of-age, heartfelt story about a girl who wants to find her friends may just turn into a story about how she finds herself.
Good Points
Bunny finds, through her getting into trouble experiment, that sometimes things aren’t quite what they seem, and sometimes what you’re looking for may be right under your nose, even if you’re not seeing it. This coming-of-age, heartfelt story about a girl who wants to find her friends may just turn into a story about how she finds herself.
Comments (0) | Was this review helpful? 0 0
More constructive book about school jitters
(Updated: June 04, 2026)
Overall rating
 
4.7
Plot
 
5.0
Characters
 
4.0
Writing Style
 
5.0
Illustrations/Photos (if applicable)
 
N/A
Theodosia "Bunny" Baxter lives with her older sister, Bella, her veterinarian mother, and garden designer father. She's struggled with anxiety her entire school career, but her friend Alex has always helped her out. Due to school redistricting, she will be starting seventh grade at E.D. Britt Middle School when everyone else from her elementary school will be attending Wade's Run. Bunny's mother knows this is stressing her out, but also knows there is no changing it, so encourages Bunny to just do her best. While Bunny makes some good decisions (gray t shirt and shorts is excellent camoflage), she makes some bad ones as well. She borrows Bella's pink, high heeled sandals, brings along a dead cicada in a baggie as an emotional support bug, and can't manage a civil conversation at the bus stop, even though neighbor (and popular 8th grader) Kyle is perfectly nice. At school, she manages to trip on the stairs and face plant... right on Kyle's butt! Other kids make fun of her, but Sylvia feels bad for Bunny and sits with her at lunch, and they are joined by Elena. Sylvia is fairly awkard as well, and a mishap ends with the dead cicada in the food of the popular 8th grader Paige. To make matters worse, Bunny ends up in Discoveries class AND gym with both Kyle and Sylvia. Kyle doesn't say anything, but Paige is mean. Bunny hears that one of the ways students can choose an alternate school is if they are a disclipline problem, and since she already has a bad attitude, it is surprisingly easy to not turn in homework, not follow the physical education teacher's directions, and generally cause trouble. Ms. Clodfelter, the Directions teacher, is super excited about her elective class, where there aren't tests; the students all think about their place in the universe. There is a project to spend two thousand dollars in grant money, and Bunny, who is extremely interested in insects, wants to put trees and a butterfly garden near the outdoor bleachers. Other projects include a photocollage of students and buying picture books for the library, and the class will vote. Bunny has found out that if she gets expelled, she doesn't get to pick an alternate school, she will get sent to The Alternative Learning Center, which is a completely different thing. Since she is now invested in her project, and has actually been making friends, she has a difficult decision when the superintendent agrees to let her transfer back to Wade's Run. Alex is invested in volleyball and her new friends, and Bunny starts to realize that she would rather compete in the Challenge Day competition at her new school, since she's discovered quite a talent for badminton. Will she stay at her new school?
Good Points
Roberts' Nikki on the Line was fantastic, so I was looking forward to this new title. There have been a lot of books lately with anxious characters, it was good to see a bit of a spin on this topic. Bunny's mother, while supportive of her daughter, also expected her to pull up her socks and get to work. Bunny's thought that she could get transferred made sense in the way that something makes sense to a 12 year old. It was great to see that both parents, as well as Bunny's sister, were involved and around, and there is also a lot of discussion about the fact that Bunny is adopted, which is something I've not seen a lot recently in middle grade literature. The best part was probably that Bunny forgot to be so anxious when she found purpose in her gardening project and had a group of people to talk to. A lot of being anxious is just having too much time on one's hands to wallow in the anxiety.

At my school, it would be unusual for 7th and 8th graders to have any classes together, and it seemed slightly odd that there wasn't an opportunity for Bunny to apply for open enrollment. My district opened a new middle school last year, and I was surprised at how well even the new 8th graders assimilated. Every school district is different.

I'm glad that Bunny is in seventh grade, and that some of her friends are in 8th, and that she has a lot of school projects and activities in which she is taking part. I wish there were more slightly humorous realistic fiction books like this, with everyday middle school problems. I would have saved up my babysitting money to buy a copy of this title, which reminded me in the best way of Betty Miles' books or the work of Ellen Conford. Hand this to readers who love Miller's Not If You Break Up With Me First, Papademetriou's Far-Fetched, or the Scholastic WISH novels.
Comments (0) | Was this review helpful? 0 0

User reviews

2 reviews
Overall rating
 
5.0
Plot
 
5.0(2)
Characters
 
5.0(2)
Writing Style
 
5.0(2)
Illustrations/Photos (if applicable)
 
N/A(0)
Already have an account? or Create an account
Book Review: The Metamorphosis of Bunny Baxter - Self Discovery
(Updated: June 04, 2026)
Overall rating
 
5.0
Plot
 
5.0
Characters
 
5.0
Writing Style
 
5.0
Illustrations/Photos (if applicable)
 
N/A
The Metamorphosis of Bunny Baxter was another book I happened to find while browsing in the library. I ended up checking it out, and it was one of those stories I started there but finished later at home because I wanted to see how things turned out.

The story follows Theodosia, who prefers to be called Bunny. She is starting seventh grade but has to deal with a huge change after being moved to a different school district. That means leaving behind the friends she has known since kindergarten and starting over somewhere completely new. For Bunny, this is especially hard because she already struggles with anxiety and sometimes feels nervous speaking up in class or being the center of attention. She also has a strong interest in insects, which makes her feel even more different from the other kids around her.

Because she misses her old school and her friends so much, Bunny comes up with the idea that if she gets expelled from the new school, she might be able to go back to where she was before. She begins making poor choices on purpose, like refusing to do homework or acting uncooperative in class. But pretending to be the “bad kid” ends up making her feel just as uncomfortable as being the quiet new student.

What I liked about the book is that it shows how confusing middle school can be for a lot of kids, reminding me of myself when I was in middle school! People are trying to figure out who they are and where they fit in. Bunny slowly begins to realize that change is not always the worst thing, especially as she starts meeting new people and finding unexpected interests, like discovering she is actually pretty good at badminton. The story also includes some thoughtful moments with her family, especially conversations about anxiety and feeling different.

Overall, it is a realistic story about growing up, facing change, and learning that sometimes the things we try to avoid can end up helping us grow. It also includes some fun facts about insects, gardening, and pollinators, which adds an extra layer to Bunny’s character and interests.
Good Points
- Relatable story about middle school changes

- Honest look at anxiety and fitting in

- Interesting insect and nature facts

- Characters that feel realistic and different from each other
Comments (0) | Was this review helpful? 0 0
funny, heartfelt, and totally gets what it’s like to feel out of place
(Updated: June 04, 2026)
Overall rating
 
5.0
Plot
 
5.0
Characters
 
5.0
Writing Style
 
5.0
Illustrations/Photos (if applicable)
 
N/A
Middle school is awkward enough but try starting over without your best friend, with social anxiety, and in a body that refuses to blend in. That’s Bunny’s life!

After a truly chaotic first day, think: tripping, crashing into the cute boy, and starting a cafeteria riot, Bunny decides her new goal is to get expelled so she can transfer schools. What could go wrong, right?

Turns out, getting in trouble is easy! Figuring out what you actually want? Way harder!

This book is funny, heartfelt, and totally gets what it’s like to feel out of place. Bunny’s voice is awkwardly perfect, and her journey from trying to disappear to learning how to stand out is so relatable and sweet.
Comments (0) | Was this review helpful? 0 0